Blog

The 5 Best Oven Liners of 2023

When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Cleaning your oven is a dreadful task, but a quality oven liner can ease the burden of this necessary chore. Oven liners live on the bottom rack of your oven to catch drips, burnt bits, and other cooking debris. We found the best choices for all oven types, plus options made from heavy-duty materials, customizable mats, and more. (If you're using your air fryer more than the oven these days, check out the best silicone air fryer liners.) Microwave Safe Aluminum Container

The 5 Best Oven Liners of 2023

Every liner is different, so always read the instructions carefully to ensure the one you choose is compatible with your oven type. Wrong placement can cause a dangerous reaction between the oven and the liner. Liners are designed to withstand high temperatures, but make sure to also check the maximum temperature rating to make sure it's suitable for your oven and your uses.

Best overall: MyHomyline Oven Liners - See at Amazon The MyHomyline Oven Liners work with a variety of oven types and can be cut to fit various sizes.

Best for electric ovens: Cooks Innovations Non-Stick Oven Liner - See at Amazon Cooks Innovations Non-Stick Oven Liner is an easy and safe option to slide in and out of electric ovens.

Best for fan ovens: ThreadNanny Heavy-Duty Teflon Oven Liners - See at Amazon With its heavy-duty design, the ThreadNanny Teflon Oven Liners won't flap around when you open and close your fan oven. 

Best for gas ovens: Grill Magic Premium Extra Thick Oven Liners - See at Amazon The Grill Magic Premium Extra Thick Oven Liners are a three-piece set you can cut to fit your gas oven.

Best disposable: DCS Deals 10-Pack Disposable Foil Oven Liners - See at Amazon Convenient and easy to use, the DCS Deals 10-Pack Disposable Foil Oven Liners are a step up from aluminum foil.

Pros: Versatile, durable, customizable fit

Cons: Thin, grease can be difficult to clean

Made from non-stick fiberglass fabric, this eco-friendly oven liner suits different oven types, including gas, electric, and convection ovens. It comes with four 23- by 16.2-inch silicone liners that can easily be cut to fit just about any oven's bottom rack. Its Teflon coating helps it withstand up to 500 degrees. You can also use this multi-functional liner as a baking mat or grill mat. These oven liners are dishwasher safe.

Pros: Quick installation, wipes down easily, withstands high temperatures

Cons: Thin (but deflects heat less)

This simple, but effective non-stick mat will save you time and money. It's easy to slide in and out of the oven while cooking. Electric ovens are the only oven type where you can place oven liners directly onto the oven floor. However, unless your electric oven has a visible coil heating element, you should still lay this liner on the bottom oven rack for safety; many modern ovens have hidden heating elements below the oven floor. Measuring 16.5 by 23 inches, this liner easily catches hot oven drips and spills. It's safe up to 500 degrees, but don't forget to remove it before using any self-cleaning settings.

Cons: Deflects heat more than thinner models

Some thin mats flap around every time you open and close the oven door, but this heavy-duty, two-piece set combats that problem thanks to its thick Teflon construction. It's also tested to FDA standards, so you can cook food directly on the liner without having to worry about any added flavor or smells. At 17 by 25 inches, it should fit most standard ovens, but if not, you can also easily cut it to your preference. It's safe up to 500 degrees. 

Pros: Customizable fit, relatively durable

Cons: Can crack with excessive heat

This three-piece set of thick oven liners is multi-functional, but especially great for gas ovens. Measuring 23 by 16.25 inches, these are the best liners to easily trim and fit around vents so you can ensure airflow. Be sure to include a one-inch gap between the oven and any surrounding vents. These liners also work well on stovetop burners because they are made with a heat-resistant, extra-thick material that can withstand close fire, as well as up to 500 degrees in the oven. They are also dishwasher-safe for easy reuse. 

Pros: Quick installation, safer alternative to aluminum foil 

Cons: Doesn't withstand as much heat as reusable mats

If you're making a big dinner and don't have time to clean between dishes, this 10-pack of disposable foil oven liners is a convenient way to keep the oven in tip-top shape. These liners are a durable and safer alternative to aluminum foil that you can use on the bottom oven rack. Measuring 18.5 by 15.5 inches, each sheet is big enough to catch falling food, but small enough to easily fit a variety of oven sizes. Although disposable, this pack should last you a few months. These are safe to use up to 450 degrees.

Oven liners are straightforward kitchen products, but there are a few basic considerations that will help you get the most out of one.

Ease of cleaning: If you're buying a reusable oven liner, you want one that keeps its shape and texture while undergoing regular cleaning. Thicker ones usually hold up better than thinner ones, but the tradeoff is more heat deflection.

Dimensions: Most liners are somewhat customizable in that you can cut them to fit your oven. Just make sure it's not covering the edges where air exchange is necessary.

Materials: There are always trade offs, but always check that the liner you choose is compatible with the oven in which you're placing it. Fiberglass and silicone are the most durable, but they may affect how long it takes for your oven to heat up. You'll get convenience and an unaffected oven temperature with thinner and disposable liners, though you can't use them at the higher heats.

Yes, but check that the liner is compatible with your type of oven. You also want to make sure that you stay below the maximum temperature rating for the oven liner you buy. While most oven liners are safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, broiling can be risky, and most manufacturers recommend removing your oven liner to do so.

Yes, some oven liners double as a baking or grill mat. Check the manufacturer guidelines for the top oven-safe temperature and any other safety warnings.

Your oven liner should be placed on the bottom rack of your oven unless you have an electric oven, in which case it can go on the oven floor. Confirm with the instruction manuals of both your oven and the liner.

Yes, oven liners and mats perform the same function, but it's more important to know whether or not they may also be used as baking or grilling mats.

The 5 Best Oven Liners of 2023

Foil Roasting Pan Sign up for Insider Reviews' weekly newsletter for more buying advice and great deals. You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here. Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partners. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at reviews@insider.com.